Monday, August 2, 2010

Meeting L and B

During our delegation, we took one day to visit "the other side". We went to visit some settlers. Their names are L and B and they are a couple living in the West Bank.

L was born in the United States. She converted to Judaism. B is Israeli. They both follow the Orthodox Jewish tradition. There is a lot to be admired in being an Orthodox Jewish believer. As B said, it requires that you follow over 613 rules. The lighting of the candles has to be done just at the right time.

L and B have suffered a terrible tragedy, one that they shared with us. Their teenage son was killed several years ago by a Palestinian gunman who entered a yeshiva, a Jewish religious school, in Jerusalem, and shot dead 8 students. He was one of them. L and B and their family have experienced terrible loss. My heart goes out to them.

However, L and B see nothing wrong with living on occupied land. They moved in during the 1980s. As B claims, he has Palestinian friends and teaches his high school students to love everyone, including Arabs.

According to L and B, God wants them in the West Bank and it must be settled and ruled by Jews. Palestinians must accept that. L does not believe that Palestinians face shortages of water and blames it on their government. The constant attacks by settlers on Palestinian villagers in At-Tuwani are 'understandable', even if she does not support them. She is surprised that more people are not killed.

B fought in the Israeli army. According to him, this is a war between 'civilization' and 'barbarians'. Sometimes, force is necessary to teach the Palestinians 'a lesson'.

He admits that Israeli soldiers do sometimes commit war crimes and that he is ashamed of some of his fellow soldiers. He has also told us stories of a commander who ordered his men to be careful when crossing a Palestinian field in order to not accidentally crush a cabbage. However, the IDF is a 'very moral army'. After what I have heard and witnessed in the West Bank thus far, I cannot say I agree. There are soldiers I have met who are very decent and kind, but their orders require them to treat Palestinians as potential criminals and to destroy their property. I have spoken to many Palestinians who know unarmed people who have been killed by the IDF.

I believe L and B when they criticize Palestinian leaders. The PA's corruption and heavy handedness is legendary and a glimpse of any human right's groups website will confirm that. Hamas has still not renounced its charter which outlines the twisted vision of wanting to see Israel destroyed and rockets do fly into Israel from Gaza. Few Israelis are injured or killed and although their suffering is very real it does not even begin to compare in scale to what the Palestinians are going through on a daily basis.

I've heard L and B alternate between declarations of friendships with Arabs to using words like 'barbarians' to define Palestinians and saying that 'in Bedouin culture, a boy becomes a man if he is good at stealing'. I haven't heard such racism for a long time.

L and B graciously welcomed us to their home and shared their worldview with us, along with some delicious ice cold water. They are not raving fanatics or lunatics but often smile and speak in a very calm voice.

I will not include their pictures because I did not ask them if I can post their photos on this blog. I will also not provide their names. Although we interviewed them and they did not ask us to change their names, I have decided not to include them.

I will post some photos of a suburban settler neighbourhood where we drove by at one point during the delegation. The beautiful green lawns and shrubbery around their red roofed homes remind me of some of the richer neighbourhoods in Canada. One of our team members counted 7 playgrounds in the settlement. I haven't seen one in Hebron.

No comments:

Post a Comment